Successful Long-term Investing Takes Endurance, Not Luck
What a huge difference just one month made. May 2019 was the worst May since 2010, and the second worst since 1962 . Then in June, the S&P 500 had its best June since 1955. Ever since President Trump unilaterally started the trade war with China (and the rest of the world), these ups and downs of the market resemble a whipsaw and have become a regular fixture for markets.
Growth-oriented assets dropped in May when trade tensions re-escalated. Then in June, central banks around the world caved in and started adopting an accommodative monetary stance to cushion May’s blow. Sentiments continued to improve after the G20 summit in Japan, where yet another trade truce was brokered between the US and China. In short, central banks are at the mercy of Trump’s political circus.
Figure 1 - May and June’s monthly returns drastically swing between losses and gains
Source: StashAway, Bloomberg
The trade war is starting to resemble Whack-a-MoleEverything, from stocks to bonds and gold, (and other than the US Dollar) rallied in June. Figure 1 shows how returns for “growth-oriented” asset classes (in dark blue) swang from very negative in May to very positive in June. Last month, US technology sector stocks outperformed the most with an 8.7% return. Gold and Consumer Discretionary stocks closely followed, returning 8% and 7.6%, respectively. We can attribute the 1.6% decline in the US Dollar in June to the Fed surprisingly flipping from being adamant on rate hikes to showing a “readiness to ease if necessary”.
It seems that President Trump is always angry these days, and that’s because his plans don’t exist in a vacuum, and so they are being affected by things far beyond his control. Imagine a game of Whack-a-Mole: you hit one mole, only for three more moles to pop up. In this case, President Trump whacked China with trade threats, and three new issues popped up that he wasn’t expecting. And he’s not happy about it.
What’s he not happy about exactly?
First, President Trump is angry with Vietnam because the world is circumventing the effects of tariffs imposed by the US by re-routing of trade flows through Vietnam. The Wall Street Journal  reported that Vietnam’s imports of PCs and electronics from China has increased by a whopping 81% YoY in May, and in the same month, there was also a 72% surge in Vietnam’s exports of the very same products to the US. What a coincidence...
Second, the Chinese Yuan depreciated 4.1% against the greenback during the re-escalation of the trade war between 17 April and 17 May. The depreciation of the Yuan makes Chinese imports cheaper, offsetting his tariffs.
And finally, there are the central bankers. Specifically, he’s angry with Jerome Powell, Chairman of the US Federal Reserve, because the Fed pledged a readiness to act, but hasn’t yet cut interest rates at all. For “Make America Great Again” to work, Trump needs his central bank to provide more market support than the central banks on the other side do. But central bankers on the other side, such as Mr Draghi, outgoing Chair of the European Central Bank, have been doing more to support the markets than the Fed.
These three issues, or moles, have fortunately greatly weakened the trade war’s impact on the markets. Once again, the economic damage of the trade war has been overhyped and overrated by the media.
How to survive President Trump’s wake
These market ups and downs and other external factors foiling President Trump’s plan demonstrate perfectly how crucial it is to take a long-term view with your investments. In other words, we can’t get caught up by short-term noise in the markets because we never know what else will pop up. What will Trump tweet about tomorrow?
Having just experienced May and June’s whipsaw, as well as the multiple market corrections of 2018, it’s impossible to under-emphasise how natural and unavoidable these market swings are.
What we also can’t under-emphasise is that these market ups and downs are common and quite manageable. How can you manage them? Stick. To. Your. Plan.
Dollar-cost averaging versus timing the market
Below, Figure 2 shows the price of the S&P 500 in 2018 H1 2019. In Q4 2018, the S&P 500 recorded the worst 3-month return since 2011. Then, after a horrible Q4 2018, the S&P 500 went on to record the best Q1 since 2009.
Figure 2 - Dollar-cost averaging plants the seeds for long-term success
Source: StashAway, Bloomberg
It doesn’t take an economics degree to see that there was a lot of volatility in the last year and a half. Throughout this volatile period, we’ve seen a lot of investors making reactive decisions to these ups and downs: Some were timing the market, aiming to buy low and sell high. Others got out of the market when it would drop in order to “protect their money”, and then got excited about the great sudden returns and so put more money in.
Then, there were the systematic investors: those who stayed invested with a dollar-cost averaging strategy, and didn’t bother trying to understand where the bottom of the dip would hit. They invested every month, consistently, through the ups and downs, perhaps through a standing instruction.
So what happened to the different types of investors? The people who exited the markets in Q4 2018 out of fear missed out on Q1 2019’s huge rebound. The investors who made reactive decisions ended up putting their investments through greater ups and downs in a period of such great volatility.
An effective investment plan reduces the volatility of your savings. Those with a systematic investment plan would have averaged into the market at around 2,768 (S&P 500 price) over the last 18 months, reducing the risk of buying too high or selling too low at any given time. With the current price of the S&P 500 at a record high of around 3,000, investors who averaged into the markets are now able to reap the rewards of a well-performing market. In short, averaging into the markets with a systematic investment plan is how you manage short-term volatility. Now, let’s look at what averaging into the market means for your investments in the long term:
Look at the bigger picture
If you only look at Figure 2, sure, you could think that the market is volatile. But now take a look at Figure 3: The price of the S&P 500 over nearly 40 years. Not so up and down, is it? Sticking to a dollar-cost averaging strategy for the long-term enables you to effortlessly enjoy the near 40-year growth trajectory of the markets. The way to leverage that upward trend with a systematic plan and to stop making emotionally-driven investment decisions.
Figure 3 - Getting that beautiful return requires sticking to your investment plan
Source: StashAway, Bloomberg
Sure, there will be a few exceptional (or lucky) market timers who beat everyone else in the market. But President Trump’s flip flopping and the world’s unexpected reactions make market timing and investment reactions even more difficult.
Timing the market or not sticking to a systematic plan is emotional investing, not rational investing. But because we’re humans, we tend to make emotional decisions. The economic damage from these emotional decisions is substantial both for market timers and for investors who fall prey to FOMO (Fear of Missing out: going all-in when markets are doing well) or FOF (Fight or Flight: selling everything when there is a drop in the markets). It’s possible to avoid these emotional decisions by simply sticking to a monthly investment plan.
The moral of the story here is: whoever can stay invested wins in the long term.
What is StashAway doing about market volatility?
Not much, because we already designed our long-term portfolios to withstand short-term volatility. Our portfolios are highly-diversified across asset types and geographies, and our investment team continually researches new ways to make your portfolios even more durable in the long term. This isn’t to say that you’ll never have short-term drawdowns; rather, it means that your investments will be able to recover from short-term drawdowns more quickly than if you were in a portfolio that wasn’t intelligently diversified across asset classes. These features are built in to enhance your staying power so you can achieve your financial goals over time.
All you have to do is simply be patient, ignore the noise, and stick to your investment plan. It’s ok to look at returns on our mobile app every once in awhile, as long as you keep your emotions in check.